LEGAL CASE LIBRARY
The Index
New York
New Jersey
Florida
For Attorneys
Library
/
New York
/ Medical Malpractice
Medical Malpractice in New York
20 real decisions from New York courts — what happened, what the court held, and why it matters.
The docket · 20 entries
No. 001
Badescu v. Lewis
A missed diagnosis. A child's bone cyst. And a court fight over whether a doctor's evidence was good enough. This is Badescu v. Lewis, decided by a New Yor
Read the case →
No. 002
Belotti v. Northern Westchester Hosp.
A stroke patient's care led to a medical malpractice lawsuit against a New York hospital and several doctors. This case shows how courts decide if expert e
Read the case →
No. 003
Byrne v. Finch
A man went to the emergency room with chest pain. He later needed a heart procedure at another hospital. This New York appeals case looks at whether the ER
Read the case →
No. 004
Deitch v. Sands Point Ctr. for Health & Rehabilitation
A nursing home resident fell and later died. Her family sued for medical malpractice and violations of nursing home patient rights laws. This New York appe
Read the case →
No. 005
Hanna v. Staten Is. Univ. Hosp.
A hospital was accused of missing a stroke diagnosis. This New York appeals court had to decide if the case should go to trial. Here's what happened in Han
Read the case →
No. 006
Kristie M. v. Mercy Hosp. of Buffalo
A New York court looked at a medical malpractice case involving a premature baby's care at a hospital. The appeals court had to decide if the case could mo
Read the case →
No. 007
Lopresti v. Alzoobaee
Can a doctor win a malpractice case just by saying their mistake didn't cause harm? A New York court said no, without real proof. Here's what happened in L
Read the case →
No. 008
Napolitano v. Wighton
A hospital fall. A lawsuit. And a big legal question: who can be held responsible? Today we look at Napolitano v. Wighton, a 2025 New York appeals court de
Read the case →
No. 009
Ojeda v. Barabe
A woman went to the ER with a bad headache. Weeks later, she died. Her family sued for medical malpractice. This case looks at what a hospital and doctor m
Read the case →
No. 010
Paglinawan v. Ing-Yann Jeng
A woman diagnosed with breast cancer sued her doctor, claiming he missed early warning signs. New York's appeals court had to decide if her case could go t
Read the case →
No. 011
Paxton v. Sosnowski
A hospital patient died after being treated for suspected sepsis. His family sued an infectious disease doctor for malpractice. New York's appellate court
Read the case →
No. 012
Petrolito-McCort v. Latefi
A neck surgery led to a second surgery years later. This New York appeals court case looks at conflicting medical opinions and whether a lawsuit can be upd
Read the case →
No. 013
Peynado v. Woodhull Med. & Mental Health Ctr.
A patient claimed a hospital failed to help him after he had a reaction to a medical dye. What happened next reveals how tough medical malpractice cases ca
Read the case →
No. 014
Sanchez v. Ashraf
A knee surgery case shows how tough it is to win a medical malpractice appeal. This is Sanchez v. Ashraf, decided by a New York appeals court in 2025.
Read the case →
No. 015
Shouldis v. Strange
Can a jury's decision on medical malpractice be thrown out by a judge? This New York case looks at a wrongful death claim after a patient's suicide, and wh
Read the case →
No. 016
Sobirov v. Tetsoti
Can a doctor from another country testify about medical care in New York? A New York court answered that question in Sobirov v. Tetsoti. Here's what happen
Read the case →
No. 017
Torres v. New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.
Can a patient's own missed follow-up appointment affect a malpractice case? A New York court looked at this question after a hospital emergency room visit
Read the case →
No. 018
Weintroub v. Maimonides Med. Ctr.
A New York surgery case asked a key question: what does a patient need to fight back against a doctor's request to end a malpractice case early? Let's look
Read the case →
No. 019
Williams v. Levine
A New York patient sued her surgeons after spinal surgery, claiming malpractice and lack of informed consent. Williams v. Levine shows how courts decide wh
Read the case →
No. 020
Zappia v. Cai
A young woman had a heart procedure that led to serious complications. Did her doctor make a mistake? A New York appeals court weighed in on whether this m
Read the case →
The Index
For Attorneys